Men & Fish: 10 Other Things Men Should Hold in Dating Profile Pics

Men & Fish: 10 Other Things Men Should Hold in Dating Profile Pics

Posted by Cassie Ciopryna on March 28, 2016
Author Bio
Cassie Ciopryna
69 posts so far

Fish in profile pics. It’s a thing and we’re not sure why. A study by FishBrain  noticed the growing trend of people holding fish in their dating profiles. Their analysis showed that on Tinder 22% of young Floridian males choose include a fish-pic, NYC 5% and London just 1%. But the weirdness goes on… A survey of 1,000 members of the Alpha Epsilon Phi (AEPhi) sorority revealed that 46% of young American women found Tinder photos of men holding a fish more attractive than those of men without.

Which got us thinking… What’s this all about? Why do these men love showing off the fish they’ve caught in photos, especially to lure in potential dates? I’m pretty sure if women had fish posted all over their online sites, it’d have quite the opposite effect on men because, well, I won’t even go there.

So we thought of 10 things we’d much rather see these men holding than a big smelly trout (that’s a type of fish you try to catch, right?!)

A Dog

This is simple enough. Everyone loves these cuddly creatures. We all may have a difference in what breed of dog we enjoy most (CORGIS) but it’s a pretty safe bet that most people like a furry friend.


A Woman

Just kidding, this is just as terrible, if not worse. We’re not sure if these guys want to show how much ladies love them when the post a bunch of pictures with women flocking around them, or if they just are players. Not a good look, guys. (Unless it’s your niece—aww—but we know the game you’re getting at there too)


A Piece of Pizza

Who doesn’t love a piece of pizza, especially when it’s near an equally hot, perhaps, cheesy, man?! The only thing better here is if you could get us in the equation now. A little Lady and the Tramp action, perhaps? Actually on second thought, I want my own piece. No sharing pizza here.


A Stuffed Animal

Maybe you won it at a fair, maybe it’s something you’ve had since childhood. As long as you don’t need it to sleep next to every night, let the “awws” ensue.



Preferably we’d like to see you holding these in front of our faces before we receive them, but even if you’re near some sort of plant or nature, that’s cool too! It’s nice to see a guy showing off his sweet, feminine side once and a while.


A Drink

A craft beer, bottle of water, coffee… whatever the beverage may be, it shows you’re social! Maybe you’re holding a bottle of water while out on a run (athletic and healthy), enjoying a beer with a buddy (fun!), or sipping a fancy drink on vaca… it shows that you get out of the house (and just look hot holding something). Hello, why do you think @menandcoffee has so many Instagram followers?! But please, save those college beer funnel or shotgun pics for your old Facebook photo albums. That’s not what we’re looking for here.


A Football

Or basketball, tennis ball, soccer ball…you get the point (just not your own balls, please). Showing that you play some sort of sport (even if just for fun) is great! Maybe it’s not a ball but a surfboard, running shoes, whatever—being active and into something other than sitting on your ass all day is a sure way to make women more interested.


A Penguin

Just kidding, who can hold a penguin?! I’d be very impressed though (and jealous).


A Spatula

Any cooking tool would suffice. Tongs, pot holders, a pan… Nothing is sexier than a guy who’s got it down on the grill or in the kitchen.


A Book

It’s refreshing to see a guy that has the brains to match the looks. Show off the smarts and the face at the same time!


So guys, please, let’s re-think the whole fish thing. There are way better things to be holding in your pictures if you want the end game to be holding one of us afterwards.


what do you think?





Help! I forgot my username / password


Men & Fish: 10 Other Things Men Should Hold in Dating Profile Pics

Write for Us

Excellent! We’re thrilled you’d like to write for us. To get this ball rolling, tell us...